Sell Your Board Game & Kickstarter Game Collection in Jacksonville, FL
We Buy Kickstarter Exclusives, Strategy Games, Euro Games & More
Have a shelf (or a closet) full of board games you no longer play? Templar Toys buys board game collections — especially Kickstarter exclusives, premium strategy games, and out-of-print titles that are hard to find on retail shelves.
Whether you backed dozens of Kickstarter campaigns or built a curated collection of Euro games, we pay cash and pick up locally throughout Northeast Florida.
What Board Games Do We Buy?
We're primarily interested in collectible, out-of-print, and Kickstarter-exclusive board games — not mass-market titles you'd find at Target. If it has collector value, we want to hear about it.
Types of Games We Buy
Kickstarter Exclusives
Games and expansions only available through Kickstarter campaigns, including all-in pledges, exclusive stretch goals, and limited deluxe editions. CMON, Awaken Realms, Chip Theory Games, and others.
Strategy & Euro Games
Premium strategy games from publishers like Fantasy Flight, Stonemaier, Leder Games, Splotter, and Czech Games Edition. Especially interested in out-of-print titles.
Dungeon Crawlers & Campaign Games
Gloomhaven, Kingdom Death Monster, Descent, Middara, Tainted Grail, and similar narrative campaign games — particularly with all expansions and content.
Out-of-Print & Rare Titles
Games no longer in production that command a premium on the secondary market. Limited print runs, convention exclusives, and first editions.
Items We Buy
- Kickstarter exclusive games and expansions
- Deluxe and all-in pledge editions
- Out-of-print strategy and Euro games
- Campaign and dungeon crawler games
- New in shrink and opened-but-complete games
- Upgraded components (metal coins, custom inserts)
- Game expansions and promos
- Vintage and collectible board games
Note: We generally do not buy mass-market games like Monopoly, Scrabble, or other titles widely available at retail. We focus on collector and hobbyist games with secondary market value.
Who Sells Board Games to Us?
Kickstarter Backers
Backed more campaigns than you can play? We buy entire Kickstarter collections — sealed or opened. All-in pledges with exclusive content are especially desirable.
Hobbyists Downsizing
Collection outgrown your shelf space? Sell us the games you no longer play and keep the ones you love. We buy partial collections too.
Moving or Life Changes
Board game collections are heavy and take up space. If you need to downsize quickly, we'll buy the whole lot in one visit.
How to Sell Your Board Games
Contact Us
Send photos or a list of your games via text, email, or the form below. Note whether games are sealed, complete, or missing components.
Free Evaluation
We'll research current secondary market values and make a no-obligation cash offer within 1–3 business days.
Get Paid
Accept the offer and we'll pick up at your location. Cash paid on the spot.
Send Us Your Collection Details
Serving Jacksonville & Northeast Florida
We are based in Jacksonville, FL and provide free local pickup throughout the region, including:
Frequently Asked Questions
Many Kickstarter-exclusive games command significant premiums on the secondary market, especially all-in pledges with exclusive content that can't be purchased at retail. Games from publishers like CMON, Awaken Realms, and Chip Theory Games are particularly sought after. Even opened games retain value if they're complete.
Yes, as long as they're complete with all components. Sealed/shrink-wrapped games command higher prices, but complete opened games are absolutely worth selling. If you're missing a few minor components, let us know — many games still have value even with minor missing pieces.
Generally no. We focus on collector and hobbyist games with secondary market value — Kickstarter exclusives, out-of-print strategy games, and premium titles. Mass-market games widely available at retail typically aren't worth the logistics of selling.
Potentially very valuable. Sealed Kickstarter exclusives, especially all-in pledges, are the most sought-after items in the board game secondary market. Send us a list or photos and we'll evaluate the collection. Large sealed collections are some of the best lots we buy.
We don’t provide formal appraisals or market valuations. What we do offer is a free, no-obligation buy quote — we’ll review your collection and let you know what we’re willing to pay for it. Our buy price reflects wholesale value, which accounts for the time, fees, and effort involved in reselling. If you need a formal appraisal for insurance or estate purposes, we’d recommend contacting a certified appraiser.
Most sellers have a cash offer within 1–3 business days of sending us photos. Once you accept, we typically schedule pickup within a few days depending on your location and availability. From first contact to cash in hand, the whole process usually takes less than a week.
Selling a collection on eBay means photographing, listing, and shipping items one at a time — plus dealing with fees (12–15%), returns, and buyers who don’t pay. For a large collection, that can turn into a part-time job for months. When you sell to us, you get one cash offer for everything, we pick it up, and you’re done. You’ll net less per item than a patient eBay seller might, but you skip the hassle entirely and get paid immediately.
Our buy price is based on wholesale value, not retail or eBay pricing. Wholesale accounts for the time, storage, selling fees, and risk involved in reselling each item individually. The exact percentage depends on the collection — factors like brand, condition, demand, and volume all play a role. We’re transparent about how we arrive at our offer and there’s never any pressure or obligation.
Condition affects what we can offer, but it doesn’t automatically disqualify a collection. Items without original boxes, with wear, or with minor missing parts can still have value. That said, some items in poor condition or with low resale demand may not be worth purchasing. Send us photos and we’ll give you an honest assessment — if something doesn’t fit our buying criteria, we’ll let you know upfront.
Absolutely. Many sellers want to hold onto a few sentimental pieces and sell the rest. Just let us know what you’d like to keep. We’ll make an offer on whatever you’re ready to part with.
Cash, paid at the time of pickup. For larger transactions, we can also arrange payment via check or other methods — just let us know your preference when we set up the pickup.
Yes — we work with families in this situation regularly. You don’t need to know anything about what you have. Just send us photos of the collection — even overview shots of shelves, boxes, or storage areas — and we’ll identify everything, assess the value, and walk you through your options. There’s no pressure and no obligation.